RAJKOT, India — England head coach Brendon McCullum told his players they were "too nice" before the heated third Test against India, according to batter Harry Brook. The remark came as England sought to reignite their competitive edge after falling behind in the series.
McCullum's Fiery Message
Brook revealed that McCullum delivered a blunt assessment of England's demeanor ahead of the Rajkot Test, which saw tensions flare between the two sides. "Baz (McCullum) basically said we were being too nice," Brook told reporters. "He wanted us to play hard but fair, to show more aggression without crossing the line."
The message appeared to resonate, as England engaged in multiple verbal exchanges with Indian players during the match. The most notable incident involved veteran fast bowler James Anderson and India’s Shubman Gill, with umpires stepping in to defuse the situation. England’s renewed intensity, however, wasn’t enough to prevent a heavy 434-run defeat—their largest in terms of runs since 1934.
A Shift in England's Approach
Under McCullum and captain Ben Stokes, England have embraced an aggressive, free-spirited brand of cricket dubbed "Bazball." However, Brook admitted that the team had perhaps become "too passive" in their earlier matches against India. "We’re known for playing fearless cricket, but sometimes you need that extra bite," he said.
The third Test saw England attempt to recalibrate their approach, with Stokes leading by example. The skipper was involved in several on-field confrontations, including a heated exchange with India’s Ravichandran Ashwin. While the aggression didn’t translate into a win, Brook insisted it was a necessary adjustment. "You can’t just roll over in these conditions—India are ruthless at home."
Key Moments of Tension
The Rajkot Test featured several flashpoints that underscored McCullum’s call for a tougher mentality:
- Anderson vs. Gill: A prolonged verbal duel after Gill’s dismissal, with Anderson reportedly questioning the batter’s technique.
- Stokes’ Heated Words: The England captain exchanged words with Ashwin following a contentious DRS review.
- Fielding Standoffs: Multiple instances of close-in fielders engaging in stare-downs with Indian batters.
Reactions from Both Camps
India captain Rohit Sharma downplayed the confrontations, calling them "part of the game." However, he acknowledged England’s shift in demeanor. "They were definitely more vocal this time, but we focus on our cricket," Sharma said.
Former England captain Michael Vaughan offered a mixed assessment. While praising the intent, he questioned whether the aggression was misdirected. "You can’t just sledge your way to victory—especially not in India," Vaughan wrote in his column.
Looking Ahead
With the series now 2-1 in India’s favor, England face an uphill battle to level the contest. Brook hinted that McCullum’s message would remain a driving force. "We’ll keep playing with passion, but we also need to be smarter," he said.
The fourth Test begins in Ranchi on February 23, with England needing a win to keep the series alive. Whether their renewed aggression pays off—or backfires—remains to be seen.
As Brook put it: "Baz doesn’t want us to be bullies, but he doesn’t want us to be pushovers either. It’s about finding that balance."